Follow us on Twitter!

Categories
2008
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
Adams County
ADHD
advocacy
Africa
ag
ag policy
apple
apple art
Apple Blossom Festival
apple juice
apple tree
apples
art
Ask A Grower
award
bad humor
Baltimore
baseball
beer
bees
Ben
berries
Biglerville
biology
birds
blog
bloom
blossoms
Brick and Mortar
brix
bulk
buyer's club
CA storage
Camp Hill
canned goods
canning
Carlisle
CCD
Central PA
certification
charity
cheese
Chef
Chefs
cherry juice
chilies
choosing
Chuck Darwin & The Knuckle Draggers
cider
Cider Fest
Cider Town
clingstone
cocktails
colorblind
Columbia Heights
concentrate
conservation
contest
cooking
craft beverages
crop diversity
customer survey
damage
Dave
DC
dining
dinner
discounts
Donald G. Wenk
drought
Dust Bowl
education
events
Fair Food Farmstand
Family History
FAQ
FAQ market
farm
Farm Dinner
farm history
farm labor
Farm Show
farm visit
farm workers
farmers
farmers markets
Farmers on the Square
Farmers on Walnut
food
Food Alliance
Food in Jars
food policy
Food Safety
food soverignity
food system
Food Tank
Food Tank Summit
Food Trust
FOTS
FREC
freestone
freeze
freezing
frost
fruit
fun
Future Harvest
FutureHarvest
fuzz
Gettysburg
Gift Baskets
Gift Boxes
Gifts
grafting
Granny Smith
Greenbelt
Grocery Store
growing
Growing Greener
Growing Practices
guide
guster
Harbor East
hard cider
harvest
Hawkeye
Headhouse
heirloom
heirloom apples
heirloom tomatoes
HHS
history
homebrew
homewine
Honeycrisp
hot
hot peppers
humor
IFTA
instagram
Intermarche
internship
IPM
John
juice
Ken Burns
Kenilworth
Kosher
Kosher Certified
lancaster
land access
LEAF
lightning
local
lysteria
Madam Fromage
Mark Bittman
market
marketing
markets
Maryland
Maryland Department of Agriculture
Maryland Farm to Chef
Master Farmer
mating disruption
maturity
MD
meetings
merlin
Muscle Bound Lummox
music
nectarines
Nerdy ag
NRCS
nursery
NYFC
Obama
oddity
offseason
One Straw Farm
online
online orders
online store
orchards
orders
organic
Organophosphates
Orioles
PA Apples
PA Cider Fest
pantry items
PASA
peaches
penetrometer
Penn State
Phillies
Philly
photos
pictures
planting
Ploughman
Ploughman Cider
pollination
preserving
President
press
pro food
produce
profood
PSU
raptors
Reading Terminal Market
recall
recipes
Red Delicious
refractometer
restaurant
restaurants
ripe
rodents
rootstock
Roy Orbison
science
scion
scouting
seconds
seedlings
Shane
SHAP
shipping
silly
Silver Spring
social networking
South Africa
starch iodine
STEM
storage
subsidies
survey
sustainability
sustainable
Tasting Menu
testimonials
The Atlantic
tomato
Tony Danza
tour
Towson
travel
tree
trees
Trini food
Trinidad
trivia
twitter
value added
varieties
video
visit
weather
White House
white peaches
wildlife
winter
winter markets
World Series
Year in Review
yellow peaches
YGA
ZA
zagat
Mailing list sign-up
<< Back

seedlings

Posted 9/24/2009 1:34pm by Ben Wenk.

Three Springs Fruit FarmA curious web follower writes:

Legend has it that (Granny) Smith threw out cores and peels from some Tasmanian crabapples she'd used to make a pie. Since she and her husband were orchardists who grew apples themselves, surely there were domestic apple remnants in the compost pile as well.

Would a crabapple seed and a domestic apple seed both have sprouted into seedlings, then cross-pollinated? Does cross-pollinating have any effect on either variety's fruit, i.e. flavor, color, texture? Does cross-pollinating ever result in new cultivars?

Certainly there was no grafting involved, as Smith's seedling is said to have sprung up on its own, "accidentally."

I'm just wondering how this could have happened, technically.

 

Well, it's true that the parentage of the apple variety ("cultivar" to use a little grower speak) is credited to a chance seedling originating in Maria Smith's backyard in Austrailia.  Before going on, the unlikelihood of this occurring cannot be understated - most seedling apple varieties are weird and unpalatable.  The fact that such an apple did arise from such unlikely circumstances is truly remarkable.  With that out of the way, let's wade through some somewhat fantastic exaggeration and figure out how varieties come from seed.

 

First things first, one cannot get a 'Granny Smith' tree from a 'Granny Smith' seed... or you're almost as likely to get that variety as any other.  You would need to take a cutting of budwood from a 'Granny Smith' tree, as explained in "Ask a Grower, vol I".  New varieties are mostly commonly derived from chance mutations ("tree sports" or "limb sports") or clever plant breeders, just to underscore the unlikelihood of valuable varieties coming from seed.

 

little appleWhen an apple tree blooms, that blossom needs the pollen of at least one other compatible apple variety to fertilize the bloom and make a fruit.  If you're planning an apple orchard, you must plan accordingly since apples are not self-fruitful.  All of the different kinds of pollen on that bloom are combined inside the seeds when that fruit is made.  How that pollen "jives" at fruit formation and what the resultant apple cultivar that seed might produce is a big crapshoot. 

 

So if Granny Smith pitched Tazmanian apple cores into her Australian compost heap, that doesn't necessarily have anything to do with the apple we all enjoy today.  The different varieties in the culls (to use another grower turn) is going to have little to do with tree that sprouts from the pile, aside from the seed had to have come from one of them. 

 

So it's not rare that new apple varieties should come from seeds, though growing apple trees from seeds is often tricky.  What is rare that an apple variety derived from a wild seed source be worth a darn, and 'Granny Smith' is!

 

 

Further "Ask a Grower" reading: